March 22, 2026 Seton Hall at Butler

(10-13, 2-6 BIG EAST)

(12-9, 5-0 BIG EAST)

Line Score
Final	1	2	3	4	5	6	R	H	E
Seton Hall	0	0	0	0	3	0	3	8	3
Butler	0	0	6	0	3	2	11	10	1

Box Score

Seton Hall

Butler

Seton Hall Batters
Hitters	AB	R	H	RBI	BB	SO	LOB
cf Angelina Benitez	3	1	1	0	0	0	0
lf Katey Brennan	2	0	1	0	1	0	0
1b Sophia DeMarco	2	0	1	2	1	1	0
rf Naya Martinez	3	0	0	0	0	1	0
2b Loreale Blake	3	0	0	0	0	2	4
dp Lea Kosinski	3	0	0	0	0	0	0
c Erin Howard	3	0	2	0	0	0	0
pr Elisabeth Figliolino	0	1	0	0	0	0	0
ss Andrea Perez	3	0	2	0	0	0	0
3b Christina Ginex	3	1	1	0	0	0	2
p Karissa Dupuis	0	0	0	0	0	0	0
Rachael Schumann	0	0	0	0	0	0	0
p Kyra Kreuscher	0	0	0	0	0	0	0
Totals	25	3	8	2	2	4	6

Batting

2B: Katey Brennan , Sophia DeMarco , Andrea Perez

RBI: Sophia DeMarco (2)

Fielding

E: Katey Brennan , Erin Howard , Christina Ginex

Butler Batters
Hitters	AB	R	H	RBI	BB	LOB
cf Cate Lehner	5	2	3	2	0	0
rf Hailey Conger	5	2	3	4	0	2
2b Kayla Preiss	3	1	1	0	1	0
1b Makena Alexander	2	0	1	1	2	0
pr Rachel Hunt	0	0	0	0	0	0
ss Olivia Robards	2	0	0	1	1	3
dp/ph Alona Boydston	1	1	0	0	2	0
Emily Todor	0	0	0	0	0	0
c Kieli Ryan	1	1	0	1	1	2
ph Paige Lillie	1	0	1	0	0	0
3b Kendall Graves	3	2	0	0	0	0
Erin Clark	1	0	0	0	0	0
lf Olivia Roberts	2	2	1	1	1	1
p Alyx Johnson	0	0	0	0	0	0
p Katie Petran	0	0	0	0	0	0
Totals	26	11	10	10	8	8

Batting

2B: Hailey Conger , Makena Alexander

RBI: Cate Lehner (2) , Hailey Conger (4) , Makena Alexander , Olivia Robards , Kieli Ryan , Olivia Roberts

Sac: Kieli Ryan

Sac Fly: Olivia Robards

Baserunning

SB: Cate Lehner , Kendall Graves

Fielding

E: Hailey Conger

Seton Hall Pitchers
Pitchers	IP	H	R	ER	BB	WP	BF	AB	NP
Karissa Dupuis (L, 3-2)	2.2	4	6	2	5	1	19	11	72
Rachael Schumann	2.1	4	3	3	2	0	13	11	43
Kyra Kreuscher	0.2	2	2	2	1	0	6	4	28
Totals	5.2	10	11	7	8	1	38	26	143

Pitching

Batters faced: Karissa Dupuis (19) , Rachael Schumann (13) , Kyra Kreuscher (6)

WP: Karissa Dupuis

HBP: Kyra Kreuscher

Pitches-Strikes: Karissa Dupuis (72-37), Rachael Schumann (43-21), Kyra Kreuscher (28-16)

Butler Pitchers
Pitchers	IP	H	R	ER	BB	SO	BF	AB	NP
Alyx Johnson (W, 3-0)	4.1	6	3	3	1	3	19	18	65
Katie Petran	1.2	2	0	0	1	1	8	7	27
Totals	6.0	8	3	3	2	4	27	25	92

Pitching

Batters faced: Alyx Johnson (19) , Katie Petran (8)

Pitches-Strikes: Alyx Johnson (65-42), Katie Petran (27-16)

Scoring Summary
Innings	Play	V - H
Butler 3rd	Kayla Preiss reached first on an error by 3b, advanced to second (1-2 SFFFBF); Hailey Conger advanced to third; Cate Lehner scored, unearned.	0 - 1
Butler 3rd	Olivia Robards lined out to lf, sacrifice fly, RBI (1-0 B); Makena Alexander advanced to second; Kayla Preiss advanced to third; Hailey Conger scored.	0 - 2
Butler 3rd	Kieli Ryan walked, RBI (3-0 BBBB); Alona Boydston advanced to second; Makena Alexander advanced to third; Kayla Preiss scored.	0 - 3
Butler 3rd	Olivia Roberts walked, RBI (3-1 BKBBB); Kendall Graves advanced to second; Kieli Ryan advanced to third; Alona Boydston scored, unearned.	0 - 4
Butler 3rd	Cate Lehner singled to right field, 2 RBI (1-2 FBF); Olivia Roberts advanced to third; Kendall Graves scored, unearned; Kieli Ryan scored, unearned.	0 - 6
Seton Hall 5th	Andrea Perez doubled, out at third lf to 3b (1-0 B); Elisabeth Figliolino advanced to third, scored on an error by rf.	1 - 6
Seton Hall 5th	Sophia DeMarco doubled to left center, 2 RBI (0-0); Katey Brennan advanced to third; Angelina Benitez scored; Christina Ginex scored.	3 - 6
Butler 5th	Hailey Conger doubled to right center, 2 RBI (0-0); Cate Lehner scored; Olivia Roberts scored.	3 - 8
Butler 5th	Makena Alexander doubled to center field, RBI (3-2 BBBKK); Hailey Conger scored.	3 - 9
Butler 6th	Hailey Conger singled to left field, 2 RBI (3-2 SBBBK); Cate Lehner advanced to second; Olivia Roberts scored; Kendall Graves scored.	3 - 11

Other Information

Location:

Indianapolis, Ind.

Stadium:

Butler Softball Fld

Attendance:

Duration:

2:00

Umpires:

Home plate - Derek Smith , First base - Gavin Ramsey , Third base - Paul Melcher

Play By Play

Scoring Summary
Innings	Play	V - H
Butler 3rd	Kayla Preiss reached first on an error by 3b, advanced to second (1-2 SFFFBF); Hailey Conger advanced to third; Cate Lehner scored, unearned.	0 - 1
Butler 3rd	Olivia Robards lined out to lf, sacrifice fly, RBI (1-0 B); Makena Alexander advanced to second; Kayla Preiss advanced to third; Hailey Conger scored.	0 - 2
Butler 3rd	Kieli Ryan walked, RBI (3-0 BBBB); Alona Boydston advanced to second; Makena Alexander advanced to third; Kayla Preiss scored.	0 - 3
Butler 3rd	Olivia Roberts walked, RBI (3-1 BKBBB); Kendall Graves advanced to second; Kieli Ryan advanced to third; Alona Boydston scored, unearned.	0 - 4
Butler 3rd	Cate Lehner singled to right field, 2 RBI (1-2 FBF); Olivia Roberts advanced to third; Kendall Graves scored, unearned; Kieli Ryan scored, unearned.	0 - 6
Seton Hall 5th	Andrea Perez doubled, out at third lf to 3b (1-0 B); Elisabeth Figliolino advanced to third, scored on an error by rf.	1 - 6
Seton Hall 5th	Sophia DeMarco doubled to left center, 2 RBI (0-0); Katey Brennan advanced to third; Angelina Benitez scored; Christina Ginex scored.	3 - 6
Butler 5th	Hailey Conger doubled to right center, 2 RBI (0-0); Cate Lehner scored; Olivia Roberts scored.	3 - 8
Butler 5th	Makena Alexander doubled to center field, RBI (3-2 BBBKK); Hailey Conger scored.	3 - 9
Butler 6th	Hailey Conger singled to left field, 2 RBI (3-2 SBBBK); Cate Lehner advanced to second; Olivia Roberts scored; Kendall Graves scored.	3 - 11

All Plays

Seton Hall Top of 1st Inning

Angelina Benitez flied out to cf (0-2 KF). (1 out)

Katey Brennan doubled to center field (2-2 KBFB).

Sophia DeMarco walked (3-1 SBBBB).

Naya Martinez struck out swinging (3-2 KBFBBFS). (2 out)

Loreale Blake flied out to rf (0-0). (3 out)

Inning Summary: 0 Runs , 1 Hits , 0 Errors , 2 LOB

Butler Bottom of 1st Inning

Cate Lehner grounded out to 2b (1-0 B). (1 out)

Hailey Conger lined out to lf (0-0). (2 out)

Kayla Preiss singled, advanced to second on an error by lf (0-0).

Makena Alexander walked (3-2 BKFBBB).

Olivia Robards lined out to 3b (1-1 KB). (3 out)

Inning Summary: 0 Runs , 1 Hits , 0 Errors , 2 LOB

Seton Hall Top of 2nd Inning

Lea Kosinski grounded out to 3b (1-0 B). (1 out)

Erin Howard singled to right field (2-2 KBKFB).

Andrea Perez flied out to cf (0-2 FK); Erin Howard advanced to second. (2 out)

Christina Ginex popped up to 1b (1-0 B). (3 out)

Inning Summary: 0 Runs , 1 Hits , 0 Errors , 1 LOB

Butler Bottom of 2nd Inning

Alona Boydston walked (3-2 BKFBBB).

Kieli Ryan grounded out to c, SAC, bunt (0-0); Alona Boydston advanced to second. (1 out)

Emily Todor pinch ran for Alona Boydston.

Kendall Graves lined out to cf (1-1 FB). (2 out)

Emily Todor advanced to third on a wild pitch.

Olivia Roberts lined out to lf (3-2 BKBFB). (3 out)

Inning Summary: 0 Runs , 0 Hits , 0 Errors , 1 LOB

Seton Hall Top of 3rd Inning

Angelina Benitez grounded out to ss (2-2 KBFB). (1 out)

Katey Brennan fouled out to lf (1-2 BFF). (2 out)

Sophia DeMarco struck out swinging (3-2 BKBBKFFS). (3 out)

Inning Summary: 0 Runs , 0 Hits , 0 Errors , 0 LOB

Butler Bottom of 3rd Inning

Cate Lehner singled, bunt (2-1 BBF).

Hailey Conger singled, bunt (3-1 BBBK); Cate Lehner advanced to second.

Kayla Preiss reached first on an error by 3b, advanced to second (1-2 SFFFBF); Hailey Conger advanced to third; Cate Lehner scored, unearned.

Makena Alexander walked (3-0 BBBB).

Olivia Robards lined out to lf, sacrifice fly, RBI (1-0 B); Makena Alexander advanced to second; Kayla Preiss advanced to third; Hailey Conger scored.

Alona Boydston pinch hit for Emily Todor.

Alona Boydston reached on catcher's interference (0-2 KF).

Kieli Ryan walked, RBI (3-0 BBBB); Alona Boydston advanced to second; Makena Alexander advanced to third; Kayla Preiss scored.

Kendall Graves reached on a fielder's choice (1-2 KSB); Kieli Ryan advanced to second; Alona Boydston advanced to third; Makena Alexander out at home p to c.

Olivia Roberts walked, RBI (3-1 BKBBB); Kendall Graves advanced to second; Kieli Ryan advanced to third; Alona Boydston scored, unearned.

Cate Lehner singled to right field, 2 RBI (1-2 FBF); Olivia Roberts advanced to third; Kendall Graves scored, unearned; Kieli Ryan scored, unearned.

Rachael Schumann to p for Karissa Dupuis.

Cate Lehner stole second.

Hailey Conger grounded out to 2b (1-1 KB). (3 out)

Inning Summary: 6 Runs , 3 Hits , 2 Errors , 2 LOB

Seton Hall Top of 4th Inning

Naya Martinez lined out to 2b (0-0). (1 out)

Loreale Blake struck out swinging (3-2 BSBFBFS). (2 out)

Lea Kosinski grounded out to ss (0-0). (3 out)

Inning Summary: 0 Runs , 0 Hits , 0 Errors , 0 LOB

Butler Bottom of 4th Inning

Kayla Preiss walked (3-2 KBBBKB).

Makena Alexander flied out to rf (3-2 BKBBK). (1 out)

Olivia Robards walked (3-0 BBBB); Kayla Preiss advanced to second.

Alona Boydston flied out to cf (0-0). (2 out)

Kieli Ryan flied out to lf (2-0 BB). (3 out)

Inning Summary: 0 Runs , 0 Hits , 0 Errors , 2 LOB

Seton Hall Top of 5th Inning

Erin Howard singled to right center (0-2 KK).

Elisabeth Figliolino pinch ran for Erin Howard.

Andrea Perez doubled, out at third lf to 3b (1-0 B); Elisabeth Figliolino advanced to third, scored on an error by rf.

Christina Ginex singled to left center (0-0).

Angelina Benitez singled through the left side (0-0); Christina Ginex advanced to second.

Katie Petran to p for Alyx Johnson.

Katey Brennan walked (3-0 BBBB); Angelina Benitez advanced to second; Christina Ginex advanced to third.

Sophia DeMarco doubled to left center, 2 RBI (0-0); Katey Brennan advanced to third; Angelina Benitez scored; Christina Ginex scored.

Naya Martinez grounded out to 3b (1-2 KFB). (2 out)

Loreale Blake struck out swinging (0-2 SFS). (3 out)

Inning Summary: 3 Runs , 5 Hits , 0 Errors , 2 LOB

Butler Bottom of 5th Inning

Erin Howard to c for Elisabeth Figliolino.

Erin Clark pinch hit for Kendall Graves.

Erin Clark fouled out to 1b (0-0). (1 out)

Olivia Roberts singled to center field (1-2 SKB).

Cate Lehner singled, bunt (0-0); Olivia Roberts advanced to second.

Hailey Conger doubled to right center, 2 RBI (0-0); Cate Lehner scored; Olivia Roberts scored.

Kayla Preiss popped up to ss (2-1 BFB). (2 out)

Makena Alexander doubled to center field, RBI (3-2 BBBKK); Hailey Conger scored.

Rachel Hunt pinch ran for Makena Alexander.

Olivia Robards flied out to rf (2-0 BB). (3 out)

Inning Summary: 3 Runs , 4 Hits , 0 Errors , 1 LOB

Seton Hall Top of 6th Inning

Makena Alexander to 1b for Rachel Hunt.

Kendall Graves to 3b for Erin Clark.

Lea Kosinski flied out to rf (2-0 BB). (1 out)

Erin Howard popped up to 2b (1-1 KB). (2 out)

Andrea Perez singled up the middle (2-2 FFBB).

Christina Ginex flied out to lf (1-2 BKF). (3 out)

Inning Summary: 0 Runs , 1 Hits , 0 Errors , 1 LOB

Butler Bottom of 6th Inning

Kyra Kreuscher to p for Rachael Schumann.

Alona Boydston walked (3-0 BBBB).

Paige Lillie pinch hit for Kieli Ryan.

Paige Lillie singled up the middle (1-1 KB); Alona Boydston advanced to second.

Kendall Graves reached on a fielder's choice (1-2 FFBFF); Paige Lillie out at second 2b to ss; Alona Boydston advanced to third. (1 out)

Kendall Graves stole second.

Olivia Roberts hit by pitch (2-2 BKSH).

Cate Lehner reached on a fielder's choice (1-2 KFFB); Olivia Roberts advanced to second; Kendall Graves advanced to third; Alona Boydston out at home 3b to c.

Hailey Conger singled to left field, 2 RBI (3-2 SBBBK); Cate Lehner advanced to second; Olivia Roberts scored; Kendall Graves scored.

Inning Summary: 2 Runs , 2 Hits , 0 Errors , 2 LOB